Jonathan Coachman said WWE made Brian "Road Dogg" James a scapegoat, tying the comment to how Netflix's WWE: Unreal showed James and Triple H disagree over Chelsea Green, TJR Wrestling reported. Coachman made the remarks on his show Coach & Bro.

James was co-lead writer for SmackDown starting in February 2024, according to Sports Illustrated, and also worked as a Performance Center coach and as Senior Vice President of Live Events before he left WWE. Sports Illustrated reported that a creative meeting shown on WWE: Unreal had James advocating for Chelsea Green to regain the Women's United States Championship, while Triple H disagreed based on the state of the women's division. Sports Illustrated wrote that the exchange appeared awkward to viewers.

Coachman connected that scene to James's exit, calling him a scapegoat. He did not say James was fired for backing Green, and the scapegoat description is Coachman's own characterization.

James has given a different explanation for leaving. He told Sports Illustrated:

"It was moving too fast for me." Road Dogg, via Sports Illustrated

He added that he had not gotten to spend a whole lot of time with his grandchildren and planned to do more of that now, according to the same report.

Fightful's Sean Ross Sapp has said he does not believe the Chelsea Green situation drove James's exit. No outlet has independently reported that James was removed over the Green discussion.

For now, the scapegoat claim rests on Coachman's commentary, while James's stated reason for leaving is the pace of the job and time with family.