No report places Sheamus at AEW Full Gear, and no outlet has reported that an AEW debut was booked for him. The speculation grew from a scheduling note in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, as relayed by WrestlingInc and Sportsnaut.

Sheamus, who now works under the name S. Farrelly, became a free agent after his WWE contract expired at the start of October. Fightful Select reported on October 2 that he had officially become a free agent, and he posted on X that day: "All challengers welcome."

Dave Meltzer then reported in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter that Farrelly, who was booked for The Big Event EXS fan convention at Suffolk Credit Union Arena in Brentwood, New York, had asked to leave the appearance early. WrestlingInc quoted the newsletter: "within the last week Farrelly asked to be able to leave the appearance early, as he said he has a wedding to attend." Meltzer called it a potential twist and wrote: "Might be nothing. Might be something."

The outlets differ on the convention date. WrestlingInc listed it as November 17, while Sportsnaut listed November 14, the same day as Full Gear. Full Gear took place on November 14 at the Mortgage Matchup Center in Phoenix, Arizona. The convention is in Brentwood, not Phoenix, and no report puts Farrelly in Phoenix.

On the AEW side, Fightful Select reported that many within AEW, both talent and executives, would like to see him in the company, and that as of October 2 no discussions had taken place between the sides. A later Fightful report, carried by Bleacher Report, said some big veteran names in AEW have advocated for signing him, but that there have not been any substantial talks to that point.

Whose wedding Farrelly was referring to has not been reported. Sheamus has not been announced for AEW, and no signing has been confirmed.