Trick Williams pinned Gunther in a dark match, a non-televised bout, after the November 9 episode of Raw in Greenville, South Carolina, Fightful reported on November 10. Williams, the United States Champion, scored the pinfall. It came two days after Crown Jewel in Riyadh, where Gunther's expected match with Finn Balor did not take place.

Sportsnaut reported that Gunther lost cleanly at Bon Secours Wellness Arena, with Williams winning via a spin kick and the Book End. Fightful noted that Gunther's last non-televised win came in August, and that his most recent television victory was also in August, over Matt Cardona.

Sportsnaut quoted Bryan Alvarez on how unusual the result was: "Gunther has never, until tonight, lost a dark match, a singles dark match, by anything other than DQ." Alvarez also said Gunther has only lost one house show in his entire career on the main roster.

Sportsnaut reported that Gunther "made the call not to travel" to Saudi Arabia for the November 7 show, where he was reportedly set to face Balor. The match was on the lineup several weeks ahead of the event, and promotional material featuring both men was spotted around the original outdoor venue, though WWE never formally announced it. Sportsnaut also reported that WWE told talent declining the trip was "something very much not being encouraged."

Wrestling Inc, writing on November 9, described the match as delayed. It reported that neither wrestler traveled to Saudi Arabia, that WWE leadership determined the bout "would be better suited with further build," and that the company felt Crown Jewel's four-match card was enough without it.

The two SmackDown stars have clashed recently. Balor revived his Demon persona with help from Danhausen to attack Gunther on the October 30 episode, according to Wrestling Inc. Sportsnaut's headline asked whether WWE is punishing Gunther for skipping the event, and it quoted Dave Meltzer saying there is "probably something to this" given the timing.

No match between Gunther and Balor has been announced since. Survivor Series: WarGames is set for November 28.